:AlFatwa International 27 - Open Letter to Mirza Tahir part 1
  Non - Arabic Articles English MUBAHILA

: AlFatwa International 27 - Open Letter to Mirza Tahir part 1
: admin

Anti Ahmadiyya Movement in Islam April 2002

Bismillah Al-Rehman Al-Raheem

AlFatwa International 27 (Urdu)

An Open Letter to Mirza Tahir, Imam Jamaat-e-Ahmadiyya

Part I

Mr Mirza Tahir Ahmad Qadiani 16-18 Gressenhall Road London SW18 5QL

Peace be on those who follow the hidayah

Sub: Khisyaana Billa Khumba Nochey - "Shaitan ke Chailae - Satan's Desciples by Hadi Ali Chaudhary"

All Praise be to Allah only, who sent his Beloved Prophet Muhammad SAAW as the Last and Final Messenger and Prophet, and gave Muslims the honour to be among His followers. Millions of my gratitude go to Allah, who gave my writings the honour of such recognition that forced you once again to stoop down to such low level, that you had to resort to personal attacks on me rather than addressing the real issues that have been raised in AlFatwa from the platform of Anti Ahmadiyya Movement in Islam. AlHamdolillah. This honour cannot be earned by one's efforts. I pray to Allah that may He protect my Muslim brethren from your fraud and deception, and bring those Muslims back to fold of Islam who have been trapped by you. Ameen.

Mr Mirza Tahir! As soon as I recieved the book "Shaitan ke Chaile", published by Jamaat Ahmadiyya, suddenly this urdu idion : Khisyanee bille khumba nochey rang in my mind. I hope you will appreciate the graphic representation of this state of your mind.

Just a cursory glance on this book published under your guidance, makes it clear that it is the same cheap manner of argument which has been the characteristic of your grandfather, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani, the founder of Ahmadiyya Movement. To boast the morale of your follower, the author of this book has unsuccessfully tried to distort the facts. (Urdu poetry translation: Truth cannot be concealed by false pretensions; Paper flowers cannot emit beautiful scent)

Mirza Tahir! It was in the Muharram of 1416 (June 1995) that upon your instructions that Naeem Osman Memon Qadiani wrote a rebuttal entitled, "Three in One" of the book by Syed Abdul Hafeez Shah entitled Two in One. Shortly after authoring this book, he died. May Allah grant him place with Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani. Ameen. Actually his book was a pathetic attempt to cover the facts mentioned in Two in One. By the Grace of Allah, the popularity had increased ever since.

Like Three in One, the new book, "Shaitan ke Chailae - Satan's Desciples", also contains a cartoon on its title. In other words you have re-lived the tradition of your grandfather and so-called prophet, Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani. Of course we have no objection on the cartoon, as we think that graphics art is an effective means of expressing happenings and one's emotions. That is the reason that we also sometimes graphically represent certain aspects of Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani's life in AlFatwa International. But Alas!! You dislike our flyers and its cartoons. So much so that in the Jasla Salana of 1995 in London, you, Mirza Tahir, expressed your anger in following manner:

"One BADBAKHT (wretched), from the area of Shaikhdom, is constantly breaking the hearts of Ahmadis in various parts of the world. Against Hazrat Maseeh Mowood, one extremely KHABEESANA (wicked) advertisement making is small leaflet, who he names it as AlFatwa, he sends to Ahmadis to break their hearts ... I have handed him over to Naeem Osman Saheb so that he may tackle him and by the Grave of God he has plenty of capabilities of defensive attacks. I had explained to him generally and now he has printed that book now. It is ready now with us. Just as he has made a picture (cartoon) of Hazrat Maeeh Mowood, we have not made the picture of that MANHOOS, that MANHOOS (wretched), but the concept of satan that prevails here in the west, we have made a picture of that (on the title of this books, Three in One)..... " (Speech of Mirza Tahir on 2nd day of Jalsa Salana, London, 1995)

BADBAKHT! KHABEESANA ISHTIHAAR! MANHOOS!! SubhanAllah! What an emotional outburst!! Probably this is your style of defensive attacks. But Mirza Tahir, by such outbursts are you trying to justify the false claims of Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani? Perhaps you have not heard the story of an Imam who was crossing a pool of sewage water when he saw a boy also crossing it; Imam asked the boy to be careful, lest he would fall. Do you know what did the boy reply? He said: You be careful, because if I fell, I will fall aone, but if you fell you will take with you all those who are following you.

Mr Mirza Tahir! The man under discussion is Mirza Ghula A Kadiani. The life of founder of Ahmadiyya Movement, his character, his writings, his claims are under scrutiny and not Dr Rashid or Syed Abdul Hafeez Shah. If Mirza Ghulam is a liar, as is proven by his writings, then he has already sent a lot of people into hell. And now after his death, wearing the cloak of his Khilafat, you are busy in making people fruit for hell. For how long are you going to continue decieving ignorant and unsuspecting Muslims?

Mirza Tahir Saheb! Through this AlFatwa 27, we are presenting you an open letter of a former Ahmadi, Brother Ahtesham-ul-Haq Abdul Bari, the founder of Anti Ahmadiyya/Qadiani Movement Bombay, India. This is actually an appeal to Ahmadis/Qadianis. At the end of this letter Brother Ahtesham has invited you or your designated person for a debate on the Lies and Truth of Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani. I sincerely hope that to protect the honour of your grandfather, you will not try to escape like your muballighs.

Wassalam on those who follow the hidayah

Dr Syed Rashid Ali Dibba, AlFujairah Dated Muharram 1423/March 2002  

Bismillah Al-Rehman Al-Raheem

Jaa Al-Haqq wa zahaq Al-Baatil; inna Al-Baatila kaana Zahooqa Truth has come and falsehood perished; verily falsehood was bound to perish.

An Appeal to Ahmadi Brothers

New Offer to Ahmadi/Qadiani brothers from Anti Ahmadiyya/Qadiani Movement Mumbai

Rs. 150,000 will be rewarded to anyone who would prove quotations from of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani wrong.

by Ahtesham-ul-Haq Abdul Bari Former Ahmadi Mumbai, India

Respected Readers. Dear Ahmadi/Qadiani brothers and friends!

Brief account of how Qadiani Muballighs fled the debates

It is the unanimous decision of nearly 1.5 billion Muslims of the world that Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani and his followers (Qadiani/Ahmadis/Lahoris) in the light of their writings are kaafirs and out of the Islam. On the other hand Ahmadis insist that they are Muslims. Who is right and who is wrong?

Dear Readers! We believe that religious differences can be amicably solved by mutual discussions. Since in this Ahmadiyya controversy, it is the public who is affected most, therefore Anti Ahmadiyya Movement decided that this issue should be settled in people's court. For this purpose, in our opinion, there can be no easier and safer method than enlightened debates. In the presence of public, not only both factions have a chance to present their point of view but the public also gets a chance to decide what is right and what is wrong.

Through AlFatwa International No. 22 (Urdu), Anti Ahmadiyya Movement challenged the Qadiani Muballighs from all over the world for a peaceful public debate, even police can be arranged if they were afraid of any disturbance. They were invited to fix a date and venue of their choice to debate the character of Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani and whether he was a liar or truthful in his claims. But Qadianis have no regard for the honour of their so-called prophet. We firmly believe that inshaAllah any person or muballigh (preacher) from the Qadiani jammat will never agree for a public debate with Anti Ahmadiyya Movement in Islam. AlHamdolillah, Mirza Qadiani and his followers has not given birth to even one person who can defend the false claims of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani. Consistent fleeing of Qadiani Khalifa, Mirza Tahir, and his muballighs from such invitations for debate hoave once again proven Mirza Ghulam to be an unmistakable liar.

You will remember that last time we had given a prized-challenge, offering Rs. 500,000 to anyone who can prove a single quotation to be wrong. But alas! Not a single person among the qadianis could find the courage to defend his so-called prophet and claim the prize. Likewise our other reward of Rs 100,000 for challenge entitled, "Glorious Victory of Islam and Humiliating Fleeing of Qadiani Muballighs from Munazirah", also went unclaimed.

Dear Ahmadi brothers! It is time for you to think. These Mirzai muballighs (preachers) habitually make tall claims in front of you and through newspapers and flyers they constantly challenge Muslims for debates and mubahila, but whenever we come forward to accept their invitation and challenge them to talk about the writings of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani, they run away. Why is that?

It reason is very clear and simple. The books of Mirza Ghulam is full of lies, deception and rubbish. We have the original books and we have read them. Hence when we request these muballighs to have face to face debate, they have no way but to escape. Yes they are always ready to trap such persons who are ignorant of the writings of Mirza Qadiani. For such purpose they devilishly engage simple-minded Muslim into the discussions about life and death of Jesus, meanings of Khatam and Khatem, by giving them distorted meanings of Quran and Hadith. Poor unsuspecting Muslim thinks that these Qadiani muballighs are making a lot of effort to propagate Islam. Thus they get a chance to decieve him. Public's attention is diverted from Mirza Ghulam and his deception and lies are vieled from their view. The fact is that when these preachers are preaching you about Ahmadiyyat/Qadianiyat, the most important thing that you have to know is the person whom these preachers are trapping you to accept as Prophet or Messiah or Mahdi, who is he? what is his character? what has he written in his books? Whether this man is truthful in his claims or a liar? But these preachers never talk to you about his person!

In November 2000, in the town of Sholapur, Qadiani preacher Mubarak Amrohi challenged all Muslims for a debate. The news was immediately conveyed to Anti Ahmadiyya/Qadiani Movement Mumbai by the local Khatme Nabuwwat office. Our delegation reached Sholapur and Qadiani preacher was informed about our acceptance of their challenge. Qadiani preachers, Mubarak Amrohi Saheb and Khizir Hayat Saheb gave an excuse of lack of preparation and asked for more time. Then overnight these preachers fled from the town. SubHanAllah! Truth arrived and falsehood perished. As a result two villages of Sholapur (Naganhali and Akalkot) denounced Qadianiyat and re-entered the fold of Islam. AlHamdolillah for that.

Admission by Qadiani Muballigh

Afterall what is the reason for this fleeing of Qadiani preachers? The reason came to light only recently. It was in March 2002 that I asked the present preacher of Mumbai, Mr Shamshad Ahmad Qadiani Saheb to agree for a debate on the writings of Mirza Ghulam Saheb. He said:

"When our supreme power did not come forward to do a debate with, what is my worth?"

SubHanAllah! Now the truth is revealed.

Although the God that used to sent wahi to Mirza Ghulam, had reassured him that:

"I will give dominance over your opponents till qiyamah." (Arbaeen No. 2, Roohani Khazain vol. 17 p. 367)

Thus Mirza Qadiani is proved a liar and his so-called God who had been sending him wahi also turned out to be a liar. DearAhmadi brothers! It is time to ponder, that to whom you are selling your faith. Yes! Qadiani preachers along with their Khalifa run away from facing the challenge of Anti Ahmadiyya Movement to discuss whether this 'Self-cultivated seedling' of the British Raj, Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani was truthful in his claims or a Liar.

Dr. Basharat Ahmad Qadiani also ran away!

The Qadiani Muballigh, Dr Basharat Ahmad of Ghazi Chawk Usmanabad 413501, had also promised me to debate with me on the truth and lies of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani. Apparently the said doctor is a very learned man. In my childhood I had listened to one of his addreses which I still remember. Alas! He also could not keep his promise and fled from the debate.

Dear Ahmadi brothers! Please read another example:

Debate with Mr Songhadwi

There lives and Ahmadi in Orissa (Cuttack), his name is Syed Hasan Rasheed Ahmad Songhadwi, address: Post Songhda, Dist. Cuttack, Orissa, Pin Code 7542021. FOr the last one year, I have been communicating with him for a debate. According to Mr Hasan Rasheed his father is the best scholar of Ahmadiyyat and an encylopedia of Qadianiyat, and especially his has great expertise in giving answers to the opponents of Ahmadiyyat/Qadianiyat in a jiffy. Therefore on behalf of Anti Ahmadiyya/Qadiani Movement Mumbai, an invitation for a debate was given to Mr Songhadwi Senior, alongwith offer to pay for his travel, boarding and lodging. He was given from 1st Sept 2001 to 30th October 2001 to have the debate.

According to Mr Hasan Rasheed, Mr Songhadwi Senior was ready for the debate, but big fighting broke out amongst Ahmadis in Qadian and the Nazir of Dawat-o-Tabligh and Nashr-o-Isha'at (Incharge of Preaching and Publication) Mr Ina'am Ghori prohibited Mr Songhadwi Senior from have a debate because many Qadiani preachers in the past had recieved humiliating defeats in such debates, for instance the Qadiani scholar of Andhra, Mr Yusuf Qadiani, whose story was published in AlFatwa 22 who recieved a humiliating defeat at the hands of Anti Ahmadiyya Movement Mumbai.

Plague and the Debate with an Ahmadi Preacher from United States

Recently the preacher from US Mr Mohammed Yunus M Farooq of Rigel Way 5400, Miraloma CA 91752, USA, challenged all Muslims for debate in Gowandi, Mumbai, India. Anti Ahmadiyya Movement was contact by the local Muslims. After a public debate, Mr Mohammed Yunus M Farooq openly accepted defeat in front of live audience including his friends and relatives. Mr Mohammed Yunus had presented the Prophecies of Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani concerning Plague as a proof of his prophethood and messengership. But by the Grace of Allah, the liar was humiliated and Islam prevailed. I pray to Allah that just as whole-heartedly he accepted his defeat, with the same ease may Allah open his heart for Islam and give him the hidayah to denounce Qadianiyat and embrace Islam. Ameen.

InshAllah in this letter, I intend to expose the myth of these prophecies concerning Plague. A video cassette of this debate is also available.

Dear Ahmadi Brothers! You know this for fact that whenever Muslims present quotations from the books of Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani, Qadiani Khalifa and his preachers reject every proof in front of you, saying that this is all false propaganda and these quotations are not present in our books. On behalf of Anti Ahmadiyya Movement I announce this once again that inshAllah no quotation has been taken out of context, nor have they been distorted. Read carefully before and after, above and below these quotations. The first Ahmadi who prove these quotations wrong in any court of law, will be rewarded with Rs 150,000. And if you can't do that, then we invite you to denounce Ahmadiyyat and re-enter the fold of Islam.

Ahmadi Brothers! I have opened eyes among Ahmadis in the compound of Ahmadiyya Mission Al-Haq Building, Mumbai, India and I have been brought up among them. I can say this with full conviction that because of ignorance from the books of Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani you have been trapped into the fold of Ahmadiyyat. How many among you have read all these books. I even firmly believe that even these Qadiani preachers have not read all these books honestly. This is the reason that they avoid discussing in front of public, lest their ignorance would be exposed. I am trying to convey to you the same facts which have been deliberately or unknowingly concealed from you. My task is to convey the truth, then it is upto you to accept the truth or reject. Guidance is in the hands of Allah. Please remember Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani Saheb said:

"it is the duty of a virtuous person that he should not let go of the ways of truthfulness, rather if a truthful word is uttered by the most lowly person, and you are wrong, then you should accept your mistake and gratefully accept the word of this lowly person, and not claim that I am better than him, otherwise in the state of pride you will never get guidance, rather such a person's faith also is in danger." (Roohani Khazain vol. 3 p. 117)

Thus I request Ahmadi brothers to accept the truth honestly. In this lies the betterment for both the worlds, otherwise you will have nothing but to feel sorry on the day of Qiyamah. In any case I have fulfilled my responsibility.

Mirza Qadiani and his Prophecies

Allah says in Quran:

"So think not that Allah will fail to keep His Promise to His Messengers. Certainly Allah is All-Mighty, All-Able of Retribution." (Al-Quran 14.47)

Same thing is said by Mirza in following words:

"It is not possible that the Prophecies of Prophets are annuled." (Kishtee-e-Noah, Roohani Khazain vol. 19 p. 7)

Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani claimed to be Imam Mahdi, Promised Messiah, Prophet and Messenger and then in support of his claims he stated:

"It should be apparent to bad-opinioned people that there can be no better test to judge my truthfulness or lies than my Prophecies." (Roohani Khazain vol. 5 p. 288)

Now if someone wants to know the reality of Mirza Ghulam A Qadiani, then he does not have to waste time in anything other than examining his prophecies. If Mirza Saheb is the true Prophet and Messenger of Allah, then it is not possible that any of his prophecies is turned out to be false. But whenever we judge Mirza Ghulam on his own yardstick, he turns out to be a big liar. Whether it is the prophecy about his divine marriage with Mohammadi Begum or the prophecy of marrying a widow, whether it is the prophecy of Atham's death or the birth of a pious son, just as much Mirza propagated a prophecy to be the test of his truthfulness, as much Allah humiliated him. IN this present flyer we are going to examine his prophecies concerning Plague.

Plague exposed the false prophethood of Mirza Qadiani

For 20 years Mirza had published the following inspiration in his book Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya:

                                "Inna hoo awa al-qarya."

For a long time he kept saying that its meanings are not understood. In 1902 Plague started in India, and gradually spread to several villages and towns, yet India being a huge country, a large portion was still safe. In the begining Qadian was also not afflicted by it. Anyway it was a unique opportunity for Mirza, opportunist as he was, to propagate his prophethood. He decided to take full advantage of the miseries of poor people, their simplicity and superstitious nature.

Fear - A Psychological Weapon

Initially Mirza and his associates started making the propaganda that since a prophet of God had been rejected therefore God has sent this divine punishment:

"Why is Punjab facing the onslaught of Plague. For us one of the reason is the God has established a Movement here, and the first people to deny (Mirza's prophethood) was these and these people gave Fatwa of kufr (against Mirza)." (Malfoozaat vol.3 p.419)

People were dying everywhere, they were panic stricken. Mirza's propaganda scared them more.

Another Scheme to trap the public:

When Mirza saw that the time was ripe, he devised another scheme to trap the simple-minded public. He announced that since Qadian is the home town of a prophet - meaning Mirza himself – therefore the divine punishment (Plague) has not afflicted this town, nor is it going to in future. Not only this, even anyone afflicted by Plague if he comes to Qadian then he will be cured. For this purpose, Mirza wrote a book entitled, ‘Kishtee-e-Noah’. Through this book, he tried to give the impression that the present Plague, like the storm in the time of Noah, will vanquish all those who did not believe in Mirza, but those who would take oath of allegiance with him they would be like boarding the Naoh's ark which will save them from divine punishment. Thus Mirza Mahmud son of Mirza Ghulam, Khalifa 2nd of Qadian stated:

"Plague is the punishment of God which was sent to support Hazrat Maseeh Mowood. If the rate of growth of our Jamaat is analysed, then it will be proven that 60 - 70% people entered our Jamaat due to Plague. I remember that during the days of Plague, daily 500, 1000 letters used to come to Hazrat Saheb (Mirza Ghulam) announcing oath of allegiance." (Sermon of Mirza Mahmud, Akhbar AlFazl Qadian vol.5 No.72 dated 9th March 1918)

Ahmadi Brothers! Did you understand something? As many ba'aths (oath of allegience) that much donations!! That was the trick!!

Mirza's Ark - Plague

Mirza Ghulam stated:

"Quran tells us that when Noah's started drowning in the flood, Noah asked him to come; he said that I do not have any need to come to you, I will climb this mountain. In other words that fool wanted to survive by his own means and methods, but God said that today no one can save you from God. Similarly in my inspiration it is stated that: 'build the ship under Our Eyes and with Our Inspiration, and address me not on behalf of those who did wrong,they are surely to be drowned. And for this blessed mosque (in Qadian) (God) said: 'and whoever enters it is in peace'. These prove that a big storm is going to come and only those people will survive who will board my ark ... and that storm is Plague." (Malfoozaat vol.3 p.418)

:   admin       (   )
: 0 /5 ( 0 )

: 26-11-2009

: 663